A Guide to Pricing for Antiques

Pricing an antique can feel like a guessing game, but it really comes down to four things: its history (provenance), its condition, how rare it is, and what the current demand looks like. Learning how to judge your pieces based on these four pillars is the key to moving past sentimental attachment and landing on a price that will actually sell.

What Really Drives an Antique's Value

You can't just pick a number that feels right. A solid price is built on evidence. The real value of an antique is a story told by its unique history, its physical state, and its place in today’s market. Let’s break down what truly makes an item valuable.

Provenance And Rarity

An item's backstory, or provenance, can send its value through the roof. Having a paper trail that connects an object to a famous person, a historical event, or a well-known maker turns it from just another old thing into a tangible piece of history.

Think about it this way: say you have two nearly identical 19th-century silver lockets. One is just a locket. The other comes with a faded letter and a photograph proving it was a gift from a Civil War soldier to his wife back home. That documented story—that provenance—could easily make it worth ten times more.

Rarity is just as important. An item that was mass-produced, like a common style of Victorian dining chair, just won't be as valuable as a limited-run Art Deco vase from a studio that was only open for a few years. It's simple supply and demand: the fewer there are, the more collectors will want one.

Condition And Market Demand

Condition is usually the easiest thing to see, but it’s also one of the most critical factors. Obvious flaws like cracks, stains, chips, or missing pieces will almost always drag the value down. That said, some signs of age are actually a good thing. A soft patina on a bronze statue or the gentle wear on a well-loved wooden chest can prove its authenticity and be quite desirable.

A bad repair can be worse than the original damage. A ceramic pitcher with a handle that’s been sloppily glued back on might become nearly worthless. That same pitcher with a clean break, however, might still hold 50% of its value. If you want to get into the weeds on this, our full https://www.curio.app/blog/antique-value-guide covers these details.

The biggest mistake I see sellers make is thinking "old" automatically means "valuable." Age is just one piece of the puzzle. A 200-year-old object might be worth very little if it's not rare, in poor condition, or nobody is looking for it.

In the end, it all comes down to market demand. Right now, mid-century modern furniture is hot, and the prices reflect that. In contrast, the ornate, heavy Victorian furniture that was popular a generation ago is much less sought-after by today's buyers. While our focus here is on antiques, these valuation principles apply across the board. You can see a similar approach in A Pawnbroker's Guide to Pawn Shop Valuation. An item is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it today.

To help you remember, here's a quick breakdown of how these four elements play against each other.

Key Factors That Influence Antique Prices

Keeping these four factors in mind will give you a solid framework for evaluating any piece you come across, helping you see beyond the surface and understand its true market potential.

How to Do Your Homework and Research Prices Like a Pro

Getting your pricing right is all about solid research. I'm not talking about a quick Google search; I mean really digging into the places where the real numbers live, like specialized archives and trusted price guides.

For example, a quick look at Christie’s digital archives can be a real eye-opener. You’ll see the final hammer prices, which often look nothing like the initial estimates. To get the full picture, I always cross-reference those numbers with resources like Kovels and old-school dealer catalogs to build a truly solid "comp file."

Uncovering Auction Archives

Your first stop should be the archives of major auction houses. You're on the hunt for sold listings that are a close match to your item in style, condition, and era. Look for the listing date, what it actually sold for (the "realized price"), and don't forget the buyer's premium.

It's common to see a 20% difference between what a dealer might ask and what an item achieves at auction. That's why having a robust comp file is non-negotiable.

Let's say you have a mid-century lamp with a retail tag of $500. It’s not unusual to see that same lamp sell at auction for a hammer price that, once you add the buyer’s fees, totals out to $620. That’s the real market value.

• Scour Online Archives: Look at the pictures and the final sale prices. You'll start to see patterns in what's selling and for how much.
• Check Local Auction Results: Don't just look at the big international houses. Local sales can give you a much more accurate sense of what something might fetch in your specific area.
• Screenshot Everything: I can't stress this enough. Save the actual sale pages and jot down the dates. This is your evidence.

Knowing the Difference Between Price Types

You'll come across a few different kinds of prices, and they aren't created equal. There's a world of difference between a retail price, an auction result, and a private sale value. A dealer's retail price has overhead and profit baked in, while auction results can swing with the market's mood.

Here’s a simple way to think about it:

Knowing which number you're looking at is crucial when you're deciding on—and defending—your asking price.

A solid comp file is your best friend when it comes time to negotiate with a buyer. It’s hard evidence.

Think of it as your sales history playbook. It lets you point to real numbers instead of just saying, "Well, I think it's worth this much."

How to Build a Killer Comp File

Putting together a strong comp file isn't complicated. Start by finding at least five comparable items that have sold recently.

When I was pricing a 1920s Art Deco vase a while back, I pulled sales data from three different places: a couple of online auctions, a private collector's forum, and a few dealer sites.

My process looked something like this:

1. Gather the Goods: Collect images and final sale prices for each of the five comps.
2. Log the Details: Record the sale date, where it was sold (the venue), and any buyer's fees so you can calculate the true total cost.
3. Do the Math: Figure out the average sale price, but also make a note of any outliers—prices that seem way too high or low.
4. Set Your Range: This gives you a realistic price window, from a "quick sale" price to what it might get on a really good day.

This is the same basic method professional appraisers use, and it gives you all the confidence you need to back up your price.

Remember that pricing antiques involves looking beyond your local market. Global trends play a huge role. The market for items over 100 years old has shown some interesting growth and regional differences, with sales data tracked across 195 countries. You can learn more about these market findings if you want to go deeper.

For even more resources, take a look at the tips in our online antique price guide.

Once you have reliable data and a clear comp file, you can set a price that feels right and attracts serious buyers.

Happy selling!

Good research gives you negotiating power. It’s that simple.

Start building that comp file today. You'll be amazed at the clarity it brings.

Assessing an Antique's Condition Like a Pro

An antique's condition is a massive piece of the pricing puzzle. It’s where so many sellers get it wrong, either by overlooking subtle damage or, just as often, failing to recognize the desirable signs of genuine age. Getting this part right is absolutely critical.

You have to train your eye to see beyond the obvious cracks and chips. A clumsy repair, for instance, can sometimes be worse than the original break. While a professional restoration might help a piece retain 70-80% of its value, a bad DIY fix could easily slash it by more than half.

Original Finish Versus Flawed Restoration

One of the biggest debates I see among new sellers is about an item's finish. For many pieces, especially early American or 18th-century European furniture, that original, worn surface—what we call patina—is exactly what collectors are looking for. The gentle wear tells the story of the object.

A classic mistake is thinking a fresh coat of varnish will boost an old table's value. In reality, stripping an original finish can completely destroy its historical integrity and send its price plummeting. An untouched surface, even with a few bumps and bruises, is almost always more valuable.

So, how do you spot the difference? It takes practice, but here's what to look for:

• Uniformity: A recent refinishing job often looks too perfect, almost sterile and uniform in color.
• Honest Wear: Original finishes show subtle variations, fading, and wear marks in high-contact spots like around drawer pulls or on the arms of a chair.
• Hidden Clues: Always check the hidden spots, like the underside of a tabletop or the inside of a drawer. These areas often hold remnants of the original finish, which you can then compare to the main surfaces.

This screenshot from Kovels is a great example of how condition notes are front and center in auction listings.

Look at how each listing points out specific details about the condition. This information directly impacts its market valuation and gives buyers the confidence to bid.

Understanding Condition Grades

To describe your items like a professional, you'll want to get familiar with a basic grading system. The terms can vary a bit, but they generally follow a predictable pattern. Learning this language helps you set a defensible price and write descriptions that build trust with potential buyers.

For a deeper dive into professional evaluation methods, our guide on how to appraise antiques offers some more expert tips.

Here’s a simple breakdown of what these grades mean:

By taking the time to meticulously evaluate every chip, scratch, and repair, you can confidently categorize your item’s condition. This detailed assessment is your foundation for setting a realistic price that will attract serious, knowledgeable buyers.

Getting a Feel for Today's Antiques Market

If you still picture a dusty, quiet antique shop tucked away on a side street, you're missing the real picture. The game has changed. Today's market is buzzing online, and it’s running on a whole new set of rules with a much younger crowd at the wheel. To price antiques correctly now, you need to understand where your piece fits in this fast-moving, global marketplace, not just its history.

The shift online is impossible to ignore. Platforms like 1stDibs and Chairish haven’t just changed the industry; they’ve turned it from a local affair into a worldwide bazaar. An obscure piece of regional pottery that might have collected dust in a corner for years can now find its perfect buyer halfway across the globe. This opens up a huge pool of potential buyers, but it also means more competition.

This digital shift is also changing who is buying. The antiques market is growing at a healthy clip—around 15% annually—and a lot of that growth is coming from younger buyers and the move online. Collectors in their twenties and thirties are all in, using social media to show off their finds and bidding in auctions straight from their phones. You can read more about this market evolution to see how old-school value is meeting modern e-commerce.

What the New Buyers Are Looking For

Today's collectors aren't necessarily hunting for the same things their parents did. That heavy, ornate Victorian furniture? It’s a much harder sell these days. Instead, people want pieces that tell a unique story and fit seamlessly into a modern home.

This has created a huge demand for certain styles and eras:

• Mid-Century Modern: Those clean lines and practical designs are as popular as ever, which keeps prices very strong.
• Art Deco: The bold, glamorous feel of the 1920s and '30s is a go-to for statement pieces.
• "Grandmillennial" Style: This is a fun one. It's all about mixing traditional stuff—like floral chintz or wicker—with a fresh, modern sensibility. It's made a lot of previously "dated" items cool again.

On top of specific styles, there’s a massive cultural push toward sustainability that’s giving antiques a serious boost. Younger buyers especially love the idea of owning something well-made that's built to last, rather than buying disposable "fast furniture." This eco-friendly angle adds a whole new layer of value, making antiques a smart and stylish choice.

When you're pricing an item, remember you're not just selling a piece of history. You're selling a sustainable, one-of-a-kind alternative to the mass-produced stuff. Highlighting that in your descriptions really connects with what modern buyers care about.

Using Social Media for Research and Sales

It might sound odd, but platforms like Instagram have become incredibly powerful tools for antique dealers. It’s a visual business, after all. Dealers use it to showcase new inventory, connect with a community of followers, and even sell items directly through their posts and stories.

This gives you a real-time feed of what's hot and what's not. Follow a few popular dealers and design influencers, and you’ll quickly get a sense of what styles are getting attention and, just as importantly, how they're being priced. Think of it as a living price guide that shows you what people are genuinely excited about right now. Understanding these modern dynamics is key to setting a price that reflects not just what an item was worth, but what it’s worth today.

Setting a Smart and Strategic Final Price

You've done the digging and given your item a thorough once-over. Now comes the moment of truth: putting a price tag on it. This isn't just about pulling a number out of thin air; it’s about creating a smart price range that gets you the best possible return while being realistic about the market.

Think of it this way: you’re trying to find the sweet spot. A good starting point is to figure out two numbers. First, the high-end "retail" value—what a fancy antique shop might ask. Second, the "quick sale" price—the absolute lowest you’d be happy with for a fast, no-fuss sale. Your ideal asking price lives somewhere in that zone.

Accounting for the Hidden Costs

Before you get too attached to that retail number, let's talk about the costs that can sneak up on you. These are the expenses that can easily turn a great sale into a disappointing one if you don't account for them from the start.

You absolutely have to build these into your price:

• Platform Fees: If you're selling online, marketplaces like eBay or Etsy will take their cut. This can easily be 10% to 15% of the final price, so it's a huge factor.
• Shipping & Materials: Don't just guess. Fragile or heavy items need a lot of bubble wrap, sturdy boxes, and can cost a small fortune to ship. Always get a real shipping quote before you list.
• Your Time: Seriously, don't undervalue your own effort. The hours spent researching, cleaning, photographing, and writing a listing are part of your investment.

For a closer look at pricing one-of-a-kind items, this guide on strategic pricing for unique products has some great insights that apply here, too.

Deciding on Negotiation Room

The final piece of the puzzle is deciding how firm you want to be. Are you open to offers, or is your price set in stone?

If you have a rare piece with plenty of recent sales to back up its value, standing firm makes sense. But for more common items, or if you just want to move something quickly, building in a little buffer for negotiation is a smart move. Adding 10-15% to your ideal price gives buyers a chance to "win" a deal while you still get the number you wanted.

Your pricing strategy should be flexible. An item’s value isn't just what it's worth historically, but what the current market is willing to pay. Be prepared to adjust based on buyer interest and new sales data.

Remember, the market is bigger than ever. With new buyers from around the world, global antique values have jumped by an estimated 15-25% in the last decade alone. By combining your research with a realistic look at your costs, you can set a price that’s not just fair and profitable, but one you can confidently stand behind.

Answering Those Lingering Questions About Antique Pricing

You've done the research, you've assessed the condition, but sometimes, you're still left with a few tricky situations. Pricing antiques isn't always a straight line, and it’s completely normal to hit a few roadblocks. Let's walk through some of the most common pricing puzzles that trip people up.

Think of this as a troubleshooter's guide for those gray areas where the right price isn't immediately obvious.

When Should I actually Pay for a Professional Appraisal?

Getting a professional appraisal is a serious step, and honestly, it’s not necessary for most items. For that charming set of Depression glass or a fairly common piece of vintage furniture, the research methods we’ve already covered will get you right where you need to be.

So, when is it worth shelling out the cash? You should seriously consider hiring a certified appraiser in a few specific scenarios:

• You've Struck Gold: If your own research points to a value north of $1,000, it’s time to get an expert opinion. This is non-negotiable for things like fine art, rare furniture, or high-end jewelry.
• It’s for Official Business: When you need a value for insurance policies or settling an estate, a formal, written appraisal from a qualified professional is required. A printout from eBay won't cut it.
• The Big Leagues Are Calling: Does your item look like something you’d see at a major auction house like Sotheby's or Christie's? An appraisal will confirm its authenticity and value, which is the first step to getting it consigned.

For everything else, save your money. A proper appraisal can run you several hundred dollars, so you want to be sure the potential return on the item makes that initial cost worthwhile.

How in the World Do I Price Something I Can't Identify?

We've all been there. You find a fascinating, beautiful thing, but you have absolutely no idea what it is. It's frustrating, but it's also where the real fun of treasure hunting begins. Don't guess—put on your detective hat.

Start by documenting every single clue the object gives you. Note the materials, look for any maker’s marks (even if they’re faint or strange), and pay close attention to the style of construction or any unique design quirks. Your first stop should be a quick visual search with a tool like Google Lens. You'd be surprised how often it can give you a solid lead.

If that’s a dead end, it’s time to ask for help from people who live and breathe this stuff.

Online forums and specialty collector groups on Facebook are absolute gold mines of information. Post clear, well-lit photos from every angle, including sharp close-ups of any markings you find. You’ll find that passionate collectors are often incredibly generous with their expertise and can point you in the right direction.

Once you have a name, a maker, or even just a time period, you can loop back to the research strategies we talked about earlier and start hunting for real-world values.

Is It Better to Sell Antiques Online or Locally?

There’s no magic answer here—the right place to sell your antique depends entirely on the item itself. The real goal is to figure out where your ideal buyer is hiding and meet them there. This decision will directly influence your pricing strategy.

Here’s a simple way to think about it:

• Big and Bulky? Stay Local. For large, heavy items like furniture, architectural salvage, or garden statues, selling locally is almost always your best bet. Platforms like Facebook Marketplace or a local consignment shop are perfect. This helps you dodge the monster shipping costs that can scare away any potential buyer.
• Small and Special? Go Global. If you have high-value, rare, or easy-to-ship items—think jewelry, coins, art glass, or small collectibles—selling online opens your piece up to a world of dedicated collectors. Marketplaces like eBay, Etsy, or specialized auction sites can fetch a much higher price than you'd ever get locally.

Just remember to adjust your asking price for the venue. You might be able to price an item higher online because of the wider audience, but don’t forget to account for platform fees—which can easily be 10-15%—plus the cost of packing and secure shipping.

---

Feeling a bit swamped by a whole house full of history? Let technology lend a hand. Curio acts like an antique expert in your pocket, using a single photo to give you instant identification, historical context, and a solid price estimate. It's time to stop guessing and start knowing.

Download Curio today and uncover the stories hiding in your home!